Is Credit Karma accurate?

Written by: Credit Karma Staff
• Updated •5 min read

In a Nutshell

The credit scores and credit reports you see on Credit Karma come directly from TransUnion and Equifax, two of the three major consumer credit bureaus. They should accurately reflect your credit information as reported by those bureaus — but they may not match other reports and scores out there.
Editorial Note: Intuit Credit Karma receives compensation from third-party advertisers, but that doesn’t affect our editors’ opinions. Our third-party advertisers don’t review, approve or endorse our editorial content. Information about financial products not offered on Credit Karma is collected independently. Our content is accurate to the best of our knowledge when posted.

Credit Karma provides free credit scores, checked daily for updates, from two of the three major credit bureaus: Equifax and TransUnion.

Those credit scores are generated using the VantageScore 3.0 credit-scoring model, which is widely used by thousands of lenders, including nine of the top 10 banks. 

Keep in mind that you don’t have just one credit score. The financial industry uses many credit scoring models, including those from VantageScore and FICO as well as proprietary models.

We’ll review how credit scores work, explain why your credit scores may differ and detail how Credit Karma provides an up-to-date and comprehensive view of your credit, including the use of Approval Odds to help predict your likeliness of being approved for a credit card or loan.

What’s a credit score?

Credit scores are three-digit numbers calculated by looking at the information in your credit reports. The most common credit scores are based on the information provided by the three major consumer credit bureaus — Experian, TransUnion and Equifax.

Think of your scores as a quick summary that helps lenders understand your financial habits and how likely you are to pay back money you borrow.

You have many different credit scores, which are calculated using credit-scoring models. These include several VantageScore models developed by VantageScore Solutions, a company launched as a collaboration by the three main credit-reporting agencies.

FICO, another popular provider of credit score models, has dozens of scoring versions that are used in lending decisions.

It’s important to remember that each scoring model offers a slightly different snapshot of your financial health, and no single score tells your entire credit story. Lenders also may take into account other factors such as your income, employment history and economic conditions.

How your VantageScore 3.0 is calculated

The VantageScore 3.0 scores you’ll see on Credit Karma are based on key factors within your credit reports. These credit factors are weighted according to their influence on credit risk:

  • Payment history (40%): Consistently making on-time payments.
  • Age and type of credit (21%): The length of your credit history and the diversity of your credit accounts.
  • Credit utilization (20%): The amount of available credit you are currently using (experts typically recommend a credit utilization ratio below 30%).
  • Balances (11%): Your total outstanding debt.
  • Recent credit (5%): New credit applications or recently opened accounts.
  • Available credit (3%): The total amount of credit you have access to.

Why your credit scores on Credit Karma may look different elsewhere

If you’ve checked your credit scores from various sources, you might have noticed they don’t always match. Your credit scores may differ for a number of reasons, including:  

  • Different scoring models: Lenders may use multiple scoring models, or proprietary ones, including those from VantageScore and FICO. 
  • Different bureau information: Not all lenders report to all three major credit bureaus, meaning one bureau might have different or more recent information than another.
  • Timing: The credit bureaus receive updates from lenders at different times throughout the month. If one credit bureau has information that’s more current than another, your scores might differ between those bureaus.

Lenders also often use specific credit scores tailored to the type of financial product you’re seeking. If you’re applying for a car loan, for example, your potential lender might pull a credit score that’s specifically tailored for auto loans.

Unlike other providers, Credit Karma is a credit monitoring tool that offers you two scores and reports from two major credit bureaus for free.

What are Credit Karma’s Approval Odds?

Beyond credit scores, Credit Karma provides Approval Odds for credit cards, auto loans and personal loans. Approval Odds assess your potential likelihood of approval for specific offers on Credit Karma.

Approval Odds are determined by analyzing your credit profile and comparing it to other Credit Karma members approved for similar products. And Approval Odds don’t just look at your credit score. They consider …

  • Thousands of data points 
  • Insights from numerous score versions
  • Real criteria that lenders use

By considering a wide range of elements, Approval Odds can give you a more reliable estimate of your potential approval than your credit score alone.

It’s important to understand that Approval Odds are guidelines, not a guarantee of approval. They are distinct from a lender’s preapproval or prequalification, which are decisions from the lender.

While Approval Odds use statistical analysis, the final approval decision always rests with the lender after you submit a formal application.

What should I do if I see incorrect information on Credit Karma?

If you see information on your credit reports that you believe is inaccurate, it could be for a few common reasons. Knowing what to do in each situation can help.

1. Check if the information is up-to-date

Timing can affect your credit scores and reports. Because lenders and creditors may report your account activity to the credit bureaus on different schedules, the scores you see may not reflect your most recent transactions. You may simply need to wait for the information to be updated.

2. Dispute any errors you find

To correct mistakes on your credit report, you can dispute the error with the credit bureau and the business that originally reported it.  You can also file a dispute directly with TransUnion using Credit Karma’s Direct Dispute™ tool, a feature that assists with correcting inaccuracies on your credit report.

3. Follow up on the dispute

The credit bureaus generally have 30 days to investigate your dispute after they receive it. If the investigation confirms the information is an error, the company that reported it must notify the credit bureaus so they can correct their records.

Next steps

Understanding the nuances of credit scores is a powerful first step in managing your financial health. 

Reviewing your reports regularly from multiple bureaus and scoring models can help you build your credit and spot potential errors or fraud.

You may also want to consider using a credit monitoring service, such as Credit Karma’s free tool. These kinds of digital platforms can alert you to significant changes on your credit reports, helping you quickly detect suspicious activity, initiate a credit freeze and report potential fraud sooner.

FAQs about Credit Karma’s accuracy

Why is my credit score different from Credit Karma?

The scores you see on Credit Karma are credit scores reported by TransUnion and Equifax using the VantageScore 3.0 credit scoring model. Thousands of lenders use VantageScore to evaluate credit. You have many different credit scores based on dozens of credit scoring models and versions.

Which credit bureau does Credit Karma use?

Credit Karma provides free credit scores that you can check daily from two of the three major credit bureaus: Equifax and TransUnion. These scores are generated using the VantageScore 3.0 credit-scoring model, which is widely used by thousands of lenders, including nine of the top 10 banks. Credit Karma is the only credit monitoring tool that offers free scores and free reports from two major credit bureaus.

Why is my FICO score different from the score on Credit Karma?

You’ll often see differences between your FICO credit scores and your VantageScore 3.0 credit scores on Credit Karma because they’re calculated using distinct scoring models that have their own proprietary formulas. While these models consider many of the same factors — like payment history and credit utilization — they weigh them differently, which can make some scores higher or lower than others. Keep in mind that scores can also fluctuate because not every lender reports your payments to each credit bureau.