Credit Advice

Have a question? Have advice to share? The combined knowledge and experience of everyone in the Credit Karma community can help you. Enter your question or help others below to get started!

Question

Question

Share this question with others:

Profile Image
What is a good credit score?
Good question? Vote for this

Asked by scooby76 2 years ago Flag this question Flag this Question

Response

28 responses

+1

Under the "How Lenders View Your Credit" my score (740) falls in the "Good Category." On the "What is a good credit score" question, it's considered "Excellent." Why the difference? Thanks.

Reply

anniebaby 2 years ago

 
+1

I have the same question as anniebaby. My score of 735 is listed merely as "good" on your Report Card. Isn't that better than good?

Another question: TransUnion just dropped my score abruptly from 759 to 735 based solely on 1 hard inquiry to my credit report. Since that hard inquiry resulted in my getting a new credit line and dropping my utilization from 59% to below 40%, shouldn't that have resulted in an _improvement_ in my score? Or at least not such a drastic drop? Thank you.

Reply

Clairissa 1 year ago


Credit quality is in the eyes of the beholder. Two year ago that was an excellent score but today many lenders are taking a closer look at credit quality. As for the inquiry, it normally stops affecting your credit score in 2-6 months. You should see it bounce back soon.

CK Moderator

Either way anniebaby your credit score of 740 should soon be at 750 or better which will qualify you across the board!

Reply

Waddy 2 years ago

 

unless they drop your score by lowering your avilable credit line to keep you paying high interest rates.
They love doing that and the feds don't care.
we need to vote people in who care about the little person.

Reply

letsmakeadea 1 year ago


Hate to rain on everybody ,but recently i went on to experians site and they no longer use fair isac scoreing system.I have a 740 score with them and they only rate me as a low c rating and anything under 730 is rated as a d .And im reading that transunion and equifax are getting ready to use the same system as experian if so a 740 score is no longer good . they claim a 840 to 990 is good.In all sounds like a big scam to me to keep loan rates high.

Reply

turbosb2 2 years ago

That is the Vantage score. It is not a "rip" just another system with another scale.

CK Moderator

 

600-849 IS GOOD AT EXPERIAN

Reply

YEABUDDY 1 year ago


Do you happen to know why if the exact same information is included in calculating credit scores? For example, the exact same data is reported on all three of my reports, but the range in scores varies by more than 150 pts. For example, my Experian score is 760, the Equifax is 695, and the TransUnion score is 617. My oldest account is 10+ yrs old, and except for one acct which shows as delinquent (and which I am disputing) the remaining 11 accounts are all in good standing and have been for more than 7 yrs. In addition, I am using about 40% of my total available credit. Each time I apply for credit and the creditor checks TransUnion, my application is rejected but if the creditor checks Experian or Equifax, I don't seem to have a problem.

Reply

KrysBee 2 years ago

That is strange. Are you getting the scores from the same source? In my experience, there has to be something different with the data. I don't recall ever seeing a 143 point different with factual data.

CK Moderator

 

wow! why so much descrepency?

Reply

munisa 2 years ago


 

I see the same issue for the credit scores. Seems like trans union is the lowest on mine also. I know you should only be using 20% of your total credit. That makes a differerence. Also I know that the more you apply for credit makes scores go down at least 7 pts if not more. It surely is a stupid game, got to have credit if you don't have the cash to buy big ticket items and than paying off all credit cards and never using them causes credit score to plummet!So it's basically a game , pay cash have no good credit score, pay credit and pay on time and keep it to no more than 20% and scores goes up! It's Our choice.

Reply

yoakum66 1 year ago


 

The same occured with my Experian credit report. my score decreased by about 150 points within two days. I have three thousand dollars in revolving credit. I made one large purchase on one account which nearly maxed it out, but left me with a combined credit usage of about 32%.

Now by per centage of combined credit usage should be 27% (they update the increase much faster than they do the decrease) and my per cent of credit usage is now 80% on the one card, 0% on the other although because they aren't in a hurry to update the decreased in balances, by combined cerdit usare is reported as 29% and 86% on the other.

And let me empaszie that I had the one card maxed once before and paid the entire balance a month or two later. It had a 0% balance for about 3 months and it was never reflected on my credit reports. I have noticed that creditors don't tend to report when the balance is 0%.

My account with a $2000 limit has a 0% balance and it hasn't reflected it eirther.

I contested the the remaining balance on two installoments loans. One should have reported zero and the other should have had a substantial decrease. Instead of updating the correct balances. The two accounts were deleted from all three credit reports. Since they were accounts in very good standing, I aske the creditors to report the paid accounts to the bureaus. Nearly four months have gon by and they still haven't been reported.

So, now my score has gone down because I have two less accounts isntallments accounts. One with a zero balance and one with a reduced balance. And my score took another hit because I no longer a have a mix of open trade lines.

And one of my mortage accounts which was paid in full  was also deleted. I have no clue why that occurred.

And then I had a revolving account that was paid in full, no late payments, a zero balance, but it reported a requred montyhly payment of $20 which was utilizied in my credit score analysis. I contested that there should be no requred payment due on an account with a zero balance.

Now that account is showing a $212 balance and its being reported as a chrage-off. I teleponed the company, spoke to a representatvie and she said that it was not reported as a charge-off and she doesn't know where the credit bureaus obtained that information. She said that she could write me a letter to submit to the credit bureaus and I should also have the credit bureaus check back with her. She will not respond to them and it should be deleted.

What is going on here? Because of no errors of my own, peferfectly good accounts are being deleted from the my credit reports, the information isn't being reproted accurately nor timely to the credit bureas, and my credit score has taken a dive. Who is responsible for this? Who takes accountablity for this? And I really think that these errors will never be corrected.

 

 

 

 

Reply

JohnHoer 10 months ago


seems to me that paying down ones own debt will bring down THE score. i own my truck and my bikes,used cash. payed off my house this year, 13yrs early. and have money in my checking/savings/cd fund and owe no one nothing. and alls i get is a score of 686 or FAIR. and to think of all the money i saved just paying off my house. their game and rules i guess. i'll stick with cash and just keep buying rare gold coins, worked for me.

Reply

hpsteam 2 years ago

I viewing my credit history on this site it states 15 years of history. I have maintained open accounts for 35 years. Credit Karma rates me as average. This appears to be a deficiency. Last month I had a 795 score, this month 794. Hard to figure out...

Reply

foobar2 2 years ago

That is an excellent score. Based on your comment, perhaps you have an average number of open accounts.

CK Moderator

Are the credit scores accurate?

Reply

MEGS1965 2 years ago

We currently pull credit scores from TransUnion

CK Moderator

On your listing as to what the credit scores mean, whether they are fair or good ect., you have 640-719 listed as good. Yet when I look at my credit score which is 699, you say that it is fair. So why do you say it is fair and not good?

Reply

joefrogcool 1 year ago

Ratings are constantly in flux based on lenders and the economy. We will review our ratings to ensure more consistency in this credit environment.

CK Moderator

Why is my credit score 724 here and 695 on the truecredit website for transunion? And why is a 724 here considered a B, where a 695 is considered a D? If I needed to get a bank loan, would they check this website or truecredit? How do I know which credit score is right?

Thanks

Reply

mjb100 1 year ago

As of Jan, 2010, TrueCredit moved to the Vantage Score system which differs from our system. Both score are right although, there is seems to be a very large discrepancy in the relative range. Are you sure both scores are the most recent?

CK Moderator

the credit folks are working a monoply on people to charge them high interest rates, it will come back on them one of these days when people get fed up and pull all their money out of the banks and rip up their credit cards.
I think the feds sould step in and place more regulations these crooks for the wait they scam people out of their hard earned money.

Reply

letsmakeadea 1 year ago

Reply To This Question


Submit Your Response
Receive Response Email Alerts

We'll alert you when a response or reply is posted to this question.

The Credit Advice pages of the Site may contain messages submitted by users over whom Credit Karma has no control. Credit Karma cannot guarantee the accuracy, integrity or quality of any such messages. Some users may post messages that are misleading, untrue or offensive. You must bear all risk associated with your use of the Credit Advice pages and should not rely on messages in making (or refraining from making) any specific financial or other decisions.

Let the community lend a hand!


100 Characters Remaining

Credit Card Offers Just For You

These are the most popular credit card offers from Credit Karma members with credit similar to yours.

Orchard Bank Visa Cards

Orchard Bank Visa Cards
Apply Now
  • Acceptance at millions of locations including website purchases and reservations
  • Your account information is updated and at your fingertips 24/7 so you can manage it your way
  • Email and text messages to remind you of your upcoming payment due date with online enrollment

Orchard Bank Classic MasterCards

Orchard Bank Classic MasterCards
Apply Now
  • Acceptance at millions of locations worldwide, including website purchases and reservations
  • Your account information is updated and at your fingertips 24/7 so you can manage it your way
  • Email and text messages to remind you of your upcoming payment due date with online enrollment

Capital One® Secured Mastercard®

Capital One® Secured Mastercard®
Apply Now
  • Get the credit you need with no processing fees or application fees
  • Automatic reporting to the 3 major credit bureaus
  • Track credit with access to your credit score and other tools
See More Credit Cards...
Welcome to Credit Karma! Like our service? Share the karma and recommend us on Facebook.