Credit Advice

Have a question? Have advice to share? The combined knowledge and experience of everyone in the Credit Karma community can help you. Enter your question or help others below to get started!

Question

Question

Share this question with others:

Profile Image
Is it better to pay off a credit card every month or make payments toward the balance every month?
Good question? +16 Vote for this

Asked by JDiGorio 2 years ago Flag this question Flag this Question

Best Response

Best Response

What’s been voted most helpful!

+12

It is almost always better to pay off your credit card completely if you have the financial means to do so. From a financial perspective, unless you have a special rate on your credit card balance (say 3.00% or lower), you are generally better off paying the monthly balance in full. An exception could be to have cash for emergencies. In today’s economic environment, having cash can be very useful should you lose your job or run into another financial emergency.

From an optimal credit score perspective, paying interest on a balance doesn’t help your score. Using your credit card once every few months is enough to build a history of responsible credit use and payment.

Reply

JRobertLaw 1 year ago

Response

34 responses

+1

Use prudent financial management. Don't charge more than you can pay off. i use quicken to track purchases and never go over my ability to pay the total charges every month.

Reply

libbycove 2 years ago

Pertaining to your answer of how it is best to pay off the balance on the card each month rather than carry a balance, if the cardholder has a fantastic promotional rate...and is in the promotional period, can lenders see this so that there is a reason the individual has a high balance on the card? Or a high balance is a high balance, and so it would bring the credit score down?

Reply

lluckduck30 2 years ago

The details of your rate and amount are not on the credit report. So the answer is: there is no distinction. It just looks like a high balance. Hopefully you will have other available credit limits with 0% utilization to compensate.

CK Moderator

If I consolidate my credit cards will it lower my score?

If I settle my debt with a card company will it lower my score?

Reply

JOHN19437 2 years ago

 

There are too many variables to give a simple yes/no answer. If you consolidate your debt, your debt to income ratio stays the same to that wont nesessaraly help your score. If you keep the accounts open and there is no fee's, (no interest charged, no annual/montly 'membership' fees) then there is no cost to you, the longevity of the accounts will help, and you wont be required to remember to make timely payments. (if 0 balance, then 0 payments needed!) Longevity of accoutns does help credit scores.

Be carefull settling debts, often card companies will offer lower amounts than due to close/write off an account which may seem like an immediate benifit, but in the long term, may cost you significantly in the form of credit dings and then higher interest rates later . If the dollar amount is substancial, it may be benificial to you. However when companies 'settle', they ding your credit report with a "bad debt/acct written off" or "sent to collections"  mark which will significantly impact your score in a negative way. When settling, ask and make certian of how they will report the account to the bureaus. Negotiate with them, they may be able to report 'closed-payed infull' perhaps for a higher settlement?

Reply

phyxlor 6 months ago


+12

It is almost always better to pay off your credit card completely if you have the financial means to do so. From a financial perspective, unless you have a special rate on your credit card balance (say 3.00% or lower), you are generally better off paying the monthly balance in full. An exception could be to have cash for emergencies. In today’s economic environment, having cash can be very useful should you lose your job or run into another financial emergency.

From an optimal credit score perspective, paying interest on a balance doesn’t help your score. Using your credit card once every few months is enough to build a history of responsible credit use and payment.

Reply

JRobertLaw 1 year ago

 
+4

It is best to use all of your credit cards at least once per month and pay off 100% of the balance.  This will greatly help your credit score and cost you nothing in interest.  If you have 4 credit cards, then  use a different one each time you fill up your car with gas.  I followed this method and it always helped my score.  On my report it says paying as agreed and payed more than the minimum.....since I always payoff 100%.  A good rule to follow is do not use the card unless you have the money in the bank, at the time you use the card.  That way when the bill comes due, you will always be able to pay it off.

Reply

dogmb40 1 year ago


 

I use one credit card to charge everything and the monthly balance can be as high as $4000 but

I pay in full based on due date. The 4000 is about 20% of my limit of 20000.  I think this is hurting my credit score. Can you comment and if it is to what extent ?

Reply

ckpooh1 2 weeks ago


+1

If you have more than one card with an outstanding amount due, but cannot afford to pay both off completely, pay the minimum amount on the one with the lower interest rate, and pay off the one with the higher interest rate first. More than two? Pay off the one with the highest interest rate first, then the next higher, and down the line. Pay the minimum on the lower interest rate cards per month to protct your record of not being late as you go along.

Reply

JerryB 1 year ago

+2

  you can pay most of it off, but you will want to leave some sort of balance on the card, even if its 5 bucks. if you pay off every month, theres no running balance to keep the flow going. lets say one month or even 3 months, you dont use it, theres 1 to 3 months of no pmt history that could be working for you by showing financial responsibility with your credit you have avaliable to you. ive found this method to be most benificial, and logical. for instance, if you pay balance off on the 21st of the month but the cc company doesnt run the account holders info till the 25th, you can so to speak, say that you were left behind, cause the names and info they pull to submit to credit bureau is only pulled from the account holders that has a balance, even if its only 5 bucks, it still counts as a balance that shows a pmt history and also will carry over. use the card once a month at least, maybe dinner or a tank of gas, pay most of it off but leave a small balance to carry over. hope this makes since and helps.

Reply

tbell3260 11 months ago

 
+3

JerryB, If I understand your response, you are NOT correct and are misleading!! Leaving any balance on the card is not required! The credit company only sees the balance that is on the account when the statement comes out each month. You should pay it all off before the due date to avoid any interest. The next statement period will then show the new purchases that were made. You should not have a balance to carry over from each month to avoid all interest. In addition, using up to your credit limit each month appears to the credit company that you are maxed out, even if you pay it off every month.

Reply

Lesismore46 11 months ago


 
+1

He's not implying it from a financial standpoint. Yes, it IS best to not owe money on your credit cards. From a credit score standpoint, (go check out the credit report card section on CK) your credit score gets lowered significanly if it shows that you owe zero dollars on your accounts. Having a $5 balance isn't going to kill anyone financially with the interest, and according to THIS SITES postings having a 1% balance on your credit card is miles better than having a 0% balance. I'm not a creditor by any means, but I did notice that myself and haven't been completely paying my CC's off each month because of it. Again, having a $5 balance isn't going to kill anyone in interest.

Reply

exolesneakzorz 10 months ago


 

Please take into consideration that credit card companies use average daily balance. I.e., if you leave $5 on your card, they will use you last month's average daily balance (and not $5) to charge interest from you.

Reply

alexey5085 1 month ago


+5

sneakzorz, you are correct that a 0% utilization of your credit cards will lower your score. BUT you are incorrect in the way you think this is calculated. As Lesismore46 stated, The balance reported to the credit agency is based on the amount that is on your bill when they mail it out (or post it online etc). They report it to the credit agency at this time, before you have even had a chance to pay it. As you know, If you pay it in full before the due date, no interest is accured. But as far as the credit reporting agency is concerned, this counts as utilization of your credit card.

 So, suppose your limit is 1000, you charge 750, and pay it off as soon as you get your bill. This will count as 75% utilization as far as the credit reporting agency is concerned, even though no interest was accrued and you paid it off immediately.

The best way to improve your utilization score in my understanding, is to use 1%-9% of your limit and PIF(pay in full) immediately when you get the bill. You don't have to carry a balance month to month and you don't ever have to pay any interest.

Sorry so long. I hope this helps clear some things up.

Reply

dees2003 9 months ago

 

dees-

I suspected that the balance reported to the credit bureaus was the monthly closing balance as reported on the statement. In an effort to manage utilization, I sometimes submit a payment before the closing date so the balance report maintains acceptable utilization ratios. Think it works ?

Reply

ricksplace 2 months ago


I have a capital one secrued credit card with a credit line of  $200. It cost me a $99 deposit and when I got the card they took $29 for the annual fee... Basically I paid $129 for $200? I was told to make more than the minimum payment but leave some kind of a balance to show payment history that is good and on time. If I have a minimum payment of $20, I will pay $40. I hope i'm doing this right. I have a question for those of you on here that may be able to answerer. When I log into my Capital One acct, it shows my limit was $200 and I've spent $138 + the $29 annual fee, leaving me a balance of $33 left. I am confused, this is why, although it says I have $33 left to spend, I really cant because I have a 22.9 apr. When I first got the card it said I could spend $171 because of the $29 annual fee. Well I only spent $138 because with a 22.9 intrest rate If I spent anymore it would have went over the $171... So why do they say I still have a balance of $33. Its like they want me to spend that amount and if I did I would go over my limit. Remember I only had $171 to spend and spent $138, $138+22.9% = $169. 60... Just shy of my limit of $171. Can anyone help me please I just want to build credit and be finacially responsible, Any help would be greatly appreciated!

Reply

jfarnsley 8 months ago

 

 

Jfarnsley, 

While you are right that you should always pay more then the minimum payment, the best strategy to build credit is to pay your entire balance every month once you get your statement before the due date.  This way it shows you have utilized your card, and have made a on time payment for that month.  The next month you can make new purchases on the card, and do the same thing.  This way you don't pay any interests(finance charges). If  you have a $200 credit limit then a balance of $138 is way too much.  This amounts to 69% credit card utilization which would have a negative impact on your score.  You should notice your score increasing once you get your balance lower. It is best to stay below 10% credit card utilization.  The higher your credit card utilization the more negative impact it will have on your score.  Once you had your card for about 6 months or 1 year you may want to try to get a credit limit increase.  As far as the anual fee.  If they applied it for the first year when you got your card then it is already part of your balance. If it is not showing up then you may want to check to see if they apply it the first year or if it is waived the first year. It is only charged once a year so if they already charged it then you don't need to worry about it until next year.  The anual percentage rate(APR) is the amount of interest that they charge per year.  To get your monthly finance charge you would divide it by 12 and apply it to any balance that was carried over from the previous month.  Again, if you pay off your balance for the current month every month, and don't carry a balance over to the next month  then you don't have to worry about being charged a finance charge.  The biggest things to remember when building your credit is to never be late on a payment, don't charge more then you can actually afford, don't let any bills go to collection including hospital bills, don't close your oldest line of credit.  I'm trying to rebuild my credit to so I know how touch that it can be.  

Reply

kevineamigh 8 months ago


 

Thannk you for that information. I will go ahead a pay off the balance that I have now with capital one and then next month I will do the same. With a credit limit of 200, what is a good amount to spend each month without exceeding the cc untilization?

Reply

jfarnsley 7 months ago


 
+1

Ideally you should not exceed 30% of your available credit limit.  With your limit of $200 the best thing you can do is:

-Limit your charges to a maximum of $60 each month.

-Pay the balance off in full each month.

Reply

LCJJohnson 6 months ago


Thanks for clarifying about carrying a balance from statement to statement. There is so much misinformation and myths out there, I'm glad there are those that understand to correct these misunderstandings.

Reply

sunk818 7 months ago

hmm, i'm not so sure...i was denied credit (citibank) with the only reason being "no revolving accounts with a balance"..not even "insufficient history" or anything...i do have a credit card that i pay in full before the due date each month so, of course, i don't show a balance. i hope that the pif advice pays off in the long run. btw, i even faxed a copy of my credit report showing my cc activity but never received a response, good or bad, so maybe not getting the card was for the best (since i've read many negative things about citibank).

Reply

mslovelyday 7 months ago

Reply To This Question


Submit Your Response
Receive Response Email Alerts

We'll alert you when a response or reply is posted to this question.

The Credit Advice pages of the Site may contain messages submitted by users over whom Credit Karma has no control. Credit Karma cannot guarantee the accuracy, integrity or quality of any such messages. Some users may post messages that are misleading, untrue or offensive. You must bear all risk associated with your use of the Credit Advice pages and should not rely on messages in making (or refraining from making) any specific financial or other decisions.

Let the community lend a hand!


100 Characters Remaining

Credit Card Offers Just For You

These are the most popular credit card offers from Credit Karma members with credit similar to yours.

Orchard Bank Visa Cards

Orchard Bank Visa Cards
Apply Now
  • Acceptance at millions of locations including website purchases and reservations
  • Your account information is updated and at your fingertips 24/7 so you can manage it your way
  • Email and text messages to remind you of your upcoming payment due date with online enrollment

Orchard Bank Classic MasterCards

Orchard Bank Classic MasterCards
Apply Now
  • Acceptance at millions of locations worldwide, including website purchases and reservations
  • Your account information is updated and at your fingertips 24/7 so you can manage it your way
  • Email and text messages to remind you of your upcoming payment due date with online enrollment

Capital One® Secured Mastercard®

Capital One® Secured Mastercard®
Apply Now
  • Get the credit you need with no processing fees or application fees
  • Automatic reporting to the 3 major credit bureaus
  • Track credit with access to your credit score and other tools
See More Credit Cards...
Welcome to Credit Karma! Like our service? Share the karma and recommend us on Facebook.