Credit Advice

Have a question? Have advice to share? The combined knowledge and experience of everyone in the Credit Karma community can help you. Enter your question or help others below to get started!


Posted in Retirement
Profile Image

Question By

0 Contributions
0 People Helped
401k loan payment
I recently changed my job. I had a 401k loan of 11k. As per the company policy, I need to pay the loan in full in 90 days otherwise face a tax penalty. In addition to that the 11k will also reported as an income. Because of this, I am thinking getting a credit card with balance transfer feature or taking personal loan to pay the loan to avoid the tax penalty.

What do you advise me? Which option will be better? I can pay 250 dollars per month either way.

Your Credit Scores Should Be Free. And Now They Are.

View your scores and reports anytime.

All Responses

Results 1-3 of 3Results per page: 5 | 10 | 25Page 1 of 1   Previous | Next
Top Contributor
713 Contributions
344 People Helped

Helpful to 2 out of 3 people

While Prime risk was correct in many things such as amounts it will cost if you do not pay off the 401k and have to pay penalty and taxes.  He is not correct that it would be better to get a cash advance from a CC to pay it off.

Even if your interest rate for cash advance was the same as buying, 15% is a good card at this time.  To pay off 11k at 250 a month would cost you over 5,000 more in interest.

So 4,800 to penalties and taxes or 5,100 in interest.  Seems that it would be better to swallow the cost, although this does not include the compounding loss of the retirement investment.  I have never seen a 401k do 15% averaged over any amount of time, depending on your risk factors a 5-10% is a much more true return.  In the end it is about a wash, and if interest charged for a loan, to repay the 401k is, even higher such as cash advance is 24% on your card, then it become more in favor of paying the taxes/penalty, espically if you can take the 250 a month and put it back into your 401k.

As stated before, the math to figuring out 401k loans and the advantage or risk of them can be very complex, espically when you try to account for compounding interest earned, and projections of rate of return on investments. Generally this is why you do 401k only for emergencies or for as short of a time frame as you can to avoid loss of compounding interest and possible job loss.

Top Contributor
82 Contributions
379 People Helped

401k loans are very expensive

Helpful to 7 out of 9 people

This response is after the 90 day window that you had to take care of this, but 401k loans have a lot of implications when you leave a job, so hopefully this will help others.

As a general rule, I don’t recommend ever borrowing against your 401k loan.  You are mortgaging your future retirement capability and put yourself at risk of suffering significant financial penalties if you find yourself unemployed and unable to pay the loan back.  Commonly you can find better loan options in the open market. 

Remember, the loan rate that you are paying to borrow your own money (even if you are paying it back to yourself) is commonly much lower than the money would be earning by itself in the 401k account.  For example, if your 401k account is averaging 15% returns and you can take out a loan from the 401k at 5%, the cost of using that money is not just 5%, it is really 10%.  This is because when you take the loan out, the money you are borrowing is withdrawn from your investments and is not making any money, the only return is the 5% you’re paying to yourself.  This means that you’re missing out on the other 10% and it’s your money you’re paying the 5% with!  So, you’re paying 5% and you’re missing out on 10% you could be earning.  If you can get another loan for less than 15%, leave the 401k intact.

What if it’s an emergency?  If you have a true emergency and really have to access the money, file for a hardship withdrawal so you get the money and don’t risk suffering the penalties, but keep in mind, you’ll still have to pay the taxes.  If you don’t qualify for a hardship withdrawal, you shouldn’t be taping into your retirement funds at all.

If you take out a loan against your 401k account, that balance will become an early withdrawal if you don’t pay it back.  This means that whatever amount is outstanding will be counted as income and you will be assessed a 10% penalty in addition.  If your case, an $11,000 loan would result in a $3,080 tax bill if you’re in a 28% federal tax bracket and don’t forget that your state will take their bit too if you live where there are state income taxes.  This would hit you for another 1% - 12.3%!  If I had a $11,000 loan against my 401k, I’d have the 10% penalty ($1,100), plus Federal taxes at 28% ($3,080), plus state income tax of 5% ($550) for a whopping total of $4,730.  At those rates, loan sharks become a reasonable alternative.

There are options to get you out of this pickle, but you don’t have much time to act.  Most plans allow only 90 days to repay the loan in full.  Make sure you check with your plan administrator as some may have different timelines and restrictions.

In most cases, seeking another way to finance the loan is preferable.  Even in the worst case scenario if you take a cash advance on a credit card, you can save money over eating the taxes and penalties.  Just make sure that you can make the payments on where ever the debt is moved.

You can get a new 401k loan if you absolutely have to.  Once you move to another company you can move your 401k into your new company’s plan.  As soon as you are able to sign up for the new 401k, start the process to roll over your money from the old plan.  Once your money is deposited in your new 401k you will be able to take the loan out again, depending on the plan rules.  Then you can pay off where ever you parked the debt.

After you get it all settled, pay off that 401k loan and don’t take another one out.  They’re risky and much more expensive than they appear on the surface.

6 Contributions
1 Person Helped

It always amazes me the 401k my money for the most part, work my whoha off to have it have an emergency and I have to pay interest and be told when to pay it back.. The almighty DOLLAR like when the merchant tells you it takes 10 days to get a refund on a card, it was taken right away their making money off mine for the 10 days I'd like to charge them interest.. America

Results 1-3 of 3Results per page: 5 | 10 | 25Page 1 of 1   Previous | Next

Your Credit Scores Should Be Free. And Now They Are.

View your scores and reports anytime.


Reply to this Question

Write your response:
Enter Your Comments

The Credit Advice pages of the Site may contain messages submitted by users over whom Credit Karma has no control. Credit Karma cannot guarantee the accuracy, integrity or quality of any such messages. Some users may post messages that are misleading, untrue or offensive. You must bear all risk associated with your use of the Credit Advice pages and should not rely on messages in making (or refraining from making) any specific financial or other decisions.