Credit Advice

Have a question? Have advice to share? The combined knowledge and experience of everyone in the Credit Karma community can help you. Enter your question or help others below to get started!

Question

Question

Share this question with others:
Profile Image
Is a new CC right for me?
Good question? Vote for this

My FAKO score (through Credit Karma) is 758. I have $4200 in CC debt that I am paying $1300 per month to bring card to 0$ balance. My credit limit is $11,500 and this is my only major CC. I have a Home Depot Card (with a CL of $1100) and a Military Star Card (with a CL of $2500) along with a Travel Card in my name (with a CL of $7,500). USAA has pre-approved me for an American Express with a high CL. I know I will have an initial ding in my credit score for the inquiry, but will having this extra CL been a long term advantage to my score? I am very hesitant. This new CC would allow me to save in the short term as I can transfer the $4200 from my other card to the new for 0%. I would probably save $150 or less in interest over the 3-4 months that I need to pay this down. Please advise.

Asked by gallaghehrdad 7 months ago Flag this question Flag this Question

Response

3 responses

Yes you shoudl take it. The ding fromt eh credit hit will pass in a few months, the extra credi availabel wil be good long term, and it will save you money on the existing debt.

Reply

ladald 7 months ago

 

I spoke with a financial advisor over the phone and he steered me away from this deal.  For one, the CC was an American Express and is not universally accepted in the states.  It is better if I travel to Europe on occasion.  I do not.  Secondly, lenders for mortgages look at your available credit to income ratio.  If I raised my total CL by $10,000 I would improve my credit utilization but will raise my credit to income ratio.  Even if I don'y use the entire CL, they look at the potential that I could.  And lastly, my main CC has a high enough limit that I am no need fo more.  So, in the short term I'd save, in the mediium term I'd gain, but in the long run it would drag me down. 

Reply

gallaghehrdad 7 months ago


You could always close the card after you are done paying it off. Then logn term you would be fine too. I mean yes MasterCard and Visa have a deeper market penetration in the US -- they are everywhere, while American Express and Discover less so. However, plenty of places do take american express and i use it predominantly. I do have one of each cards for just in case, but 90% of everything i pay is done through the AmExpress. So that particular reasoning is BS.

Reply

ladald 7 months ago

  • Prev
  • 1
  • Next

Reply To This Question


Submit Your Response
Receive Response Email Alerts

We'll alert you when a response or reply is posted to this question.

The Credit Advice pages of the Site may contain messages submitted by users over whom Credit Karma has no control. Credit Karma cannot guarantee the accuracy, integrity or quality of any such messages. Some users may post messages that are misleading, untrue or offensive. You must bear all risk associated with your use of the Credit Advice pages and should not rely on messages in making (or refraining from making) any specific financial or other decisions.

Let the community lend a hand!


100 Characters Remaining

Featured Credit Repair Service

  • Take action and start work to improve your credit, today!
  • Lexington Law helps you work toward the removal of questionable, negative items on your credit reports.
  • They have served over 600,000 clients since 1991
  • Active Concord-level clients see, on average, 8.7 removals by month 3 and 28.6 by month 12*

*Your Results May Vary

SERVICE PROVIDED BY

Lexington Law Credit Report Repair

See Details

Over 1 million negative items removed by Lexington Law last year, including:

  • Collections
  • Late Payments
  • Bankruptcies
  • Foreclosures
Call For Your FREE Consultation:1.855.255.0203
Welcome to Credit Karma! Like our service? Share the karma and recommend us on Facebook.