Credit Advice

Have a question? Have advice to share? The combined knowledge and experience of everyone in the Credit Karma community can help you. Enter your question or help others below to get started!

Question

Question

Share this question with others:
Profile Image
FHA with 3.5% or Conventional with 5% Payment - What are the Pros and Cons
Good question? Vote for this

I heard that you might need to stay 3 years if going through FHA, plus that the costs of FHA are higher due to an upfront insurance payment?

Asked by DragonBoss 6 months ago Flag this question Flag this Question

Best Response

Best Response

What’s been voted most helpful!

The conventional PMI is less than FHA PMI.  The fact that FHA has a streamline refi that you don't need a appraisal is nice but that maybe is a mute pointe right now because rates are so low.  I have had a FHA loan for six months at 5.25% and today I meeting with the loan officer about the streamline FHA refi.  The upfront insurance I payed six months ago is a 75% credit on the streamline this time because how new the original loan is.  Also most banks and lenders require +620 to +640 credit sores to be considered for a FHA loan.  Conventional is +775 in most cases and a great job.  Check with some loan officers and take a look at the payments and cost's of each but do not let them pull your score right away.  Use your CK score until your settled on a deal.  Good Luck.

Reply

nandog 6 months ago

Response

3 responses

The conventional PMI is less than FHA PMI.  The fact that FHA has a streamline refi that you don't need a appraisal is nice but that maybe is a mute pointe right now because rates are so low.  I have had a FHA loan for six months at 5.25% and today I meeting with the loan officer about the streamline FHA refi.  The upfront insurance I payed six months ago is a 75% credit on the streamline this time because how new the original loan is.  Also most banks and lenders require +620 to +640 credit sores to be considered for a FHA loan.  Conventional is +775 in most cases and a great job.  Check with some loan officers and take a look at the payments and cost's of each but do not let them pull your score right away.  Use your CK score until your settled on a deal.  Good Luck.

Reply

nandog 6 months ago

Thank you for the reply nandog, did you mean conventional loan is +775 or +675? Mine is at 750 on CK, but I think in reality it is in low 700's, because I moved most of the credit card debts to a good rate personal loan. After doing it my total credit utilization became lower than it was before. And knock on wood the overall debt is getting lower from month to month. However I played with prequalifed calculators online and I saw the Conventional loans offered better monthly payments and lower upfront cost. Still, most people whom I know go after FHA and that is what confuses me? Maybe because they don't want to try shopping arround for a conventional mortgage? I have a good job, with a strong large company, a degree and working on masters with no student loans. From the other side I have that personal loan and a some minor credit card debt on 0% balance, now. Therefore, I may need to wait a few more months to save more for the downpayment, closing costs and to decrease the debt. 

Reply

DragonBoss 6 months ago

They make conventional 5% down loans?  I thought the minimum was 10% for conventional.

Reply

callmethedude 6 months ago

  • Prev
  • 1
  • Next

Reply To This Question


Submit Your Response
Receive Response Email Alerts

We'll alert you when a response or reply is posted to this question.

The Credit Advice pages of the Site may contain messages submitted by users over whom Credit Karma has no control. Credit Karma cannot guarantee the accuracy, integrity or quality of any such messages. Some users may post messages that are misleading, untrue or offensive. You must bear all risk associated with your use of the Credit Advice pages and should not rely on messages in making (or refraining from making) any specific financial or other decisions.

Let the community lend a hand!


100 Characters Remaining

Credit Card Offers Just For You

These are the most popular credit card offers from Credit Karma members with credit similar to yours.

Credit One Bank® Visa Platinum Card

Credit One Bank® Visa Platinum Card
Apply Now
  • Pre-Qualify for a Visa credit card without affecting your credit score
  • Get a starting credit line up to $1,500
  • No enrollment fee

Capital One® Secured Mastercard®

Capital One® Secured Mastercard®
Apply Now
  • Get the credit you need with no processing fees or application fees
  • Automatic reporting to the 3 major credit bureaus
  • Track credit with access to your credit score and other tools
See More Credit Cards...
Welcome to Credit Karma! Like our service? Share the karma and recommend us on Facebook.